Showing posts with label litigation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label litigation. Show all posts

Thursday, July 23, 2009

New Rules of Professional Conduct out for Public Comment

The State Bar of California's Board of Governors, through its Committee on Regulation, Admissions & Discipline Oversight (RAD), is inviting public comment on eight new or amended Rules of Professional Conduct (RPC) developed by the Commission for the Revision of the Rules of Professional Conduct ("Rules Revision Commission").

The official Notice of Public Comment and the Discussion Draft of the proposed changes is at: http://calbar.ca.gov/state/calbar/calbar_generic.jsp?cid=10145&n=96067

The comment deadline is October 23, 2009. Comments may be submitted by mail, email, or by completing an online form.

This is the fourth set of rules changes proposed by the commission, and addresses issues of trial publicity, lawyers as witnesses, membership in legal services organizations, law reform activities affecting client interests, third party payors, aggregate settlements, and safekeeping/handling the funds and property of clients (among others).

A public hearing for this fourth public comment group is scheduled to be held during the 2009 State Bar Annual Meeting in San Diego on September 12, 2009 from 9:30 am to 12:30 pm at the Manchester Grand Hyatt in room Annie A. If you would like to testify and/or present written materials at the public hearing, contact: Audrey Hollins in the Bar's Office of Professional Competence (audrey.hollins@calbar.ca.gov, (415) 538‐2167) no later than Friday, September 4, 2009.

Saturday, July 18, 2009

Transfer on Death Deeds Bill Dies Again


As expected (see earlier post), the Senate Judiciary Committee again rejected this year's installment (AB 724) in Assembly Member Chuck DeVore's multi-year campaign to create Transfer on Death Deeds (TODD, otherwise know as "Beneficiary Deeds") in California. But it's getting much closer.

Last year, when the committee was comprised entirely of lawyers, DeVore's predecessor bill (AB 250) received only one vote on the five-member panel in the face of a killer committee analysis (pretty much replicated this year) highlighting concerns that TODD could be tools for elder financial abuse and would undoubtedly increase litigation. This year, the AB 724 failed by a narrow - and interestingly nonpartisan - 2-3 margin. Conservative Orange County Republican Mimi Walters and liberal San Francisco Democrat Mark Leno voted for the bill, while the committee's two remaining lawyers, committee chair Ellen Corbett (D-San Leandro) and vice chair Tom Harman (R-Huntington Beach) - both of whom practiced T&E law in their pre-Legislature professional lives - were joined by non-lawyer Dean Florez in opposing.

Committee members extended DeVore the traditional courtesy of unanimously reconsidering the vote on the bill, so DeVore will have one more shot next year before he's termed out of the Assembly (he's running for the U.S. Senate seat currently held by Barbara Boxer). Unless he can convince another committee member (presumably Florez) to change his mind, however, it will be up to some one else to pick up the TODD issue for the next session.

Saturday, July 4, 2009

New eDiscovery Statute Takes Immediate Effect


Litigators take note: As of June 29, there is now a new electronic discovery statute in California with the signing of AB 5 by Assembly Member Noreen Evans. As an urgency measure, the bill took effect immediately upon the Governor's signature.

In a rare (and probably unintentional) symmetry, AB 5 was enacted as Chapter 5, Statutes of 2009.

The changes made by the bill should have taken effect last January 1, but were delayed when last year's bill (AB 926 of 2008) received one of Governor Schwarzenegger's hundreds of generic "there's a budget crisis and this bill isn't important enough to spend time on" veto messages (Note: that's a paraphrase, not a quote).

The new provisions were developed by the Judicial Council's Civil and Small Claims Advisory Committee, working closely with the plaintiffs' (Consumer Attorneys of California) and defense (California Defense Counsel) bars, all of which are listed as co-sponsors of both bills.

Among other things, AB 5:
  1. Adds new definitions to the Civil Discovery Act
  2. Specifically provides that the scope of discovery includes electronically stored information (ESI);
  3. Allows propounding parties to specify the form of production for ESI;
  4. Enacts new provisions governing responses to demands for ESI;
  5. Enacts provisions governing protective orders against the discovery of ESI and motions to compel production;
  6. Enacts specific provisions regarding claims of work product or privilege;
  7. Adds a "safe harbor" provisions against sanctions to selected statutes;
  8. Does not include a "meet and confer" requirement regarding the propounding of electronic discovery.