Showing posts with label SB 490. Show all posts
Showing posts with label SB 490. Show all posts

Sunday, August 28, 2011

Mixed Week for CCBA Program

The past week was filled with both highs and lows for the Conference of California Bar Association's (CCBA) legislative program. On the high side, four CCBA-sponsored or co-sponsored bills passed their final legislative test and are being prepared to be sent to Governor Brown for signature or veto.

On the low side, one key component of the CCBA program (AB 308 - Ammiano) and another highly visible bill supported by the Conference (SB 490 - Hancock) were held in committee and now must wait for next year.

The bills that are being sent to Governor Brown included:
  • AB 433 by Assemblymember Bonnie Lowenthal would conform state law to the medical standard applied by the U.S. state department and current medical understanding of gender transition to simplify the existing process by which a transgender person obtains appropriate identification document. The bill, which is consistent with CCBA Resolution 04-12-2010 sponsored by the Bay Area Lawyers for Individual Freedom, passed the Senate on a vote of 23-13, and received concurrence in Senate amendments from the Assembly, 51-26. 
  • AB 1147 by Assemblymember Mariko Yamada would maximize the efficient use of resources by requiring social workers to include information about what age- and developmental-appropriate services teen mothers in foster care minor received, pursuant to existing law, in reports the social workers are already required to prepare. The bill is based on CCBA Resolution 03-04-2010, sponsored by the Women Lawyers of Sacramento. 
  • AB 1384 by Assemblymember Steven Bradford would authorize a court, after one year, to expunge non-vehicular infractions and misdemeanors (with specified exceptions) from a person’s record in its discretion and in the interests of justice. The bill would complete the enactment of Resolution 06-06-2009 by the Santa Clara County Bar Association, the major provisions of which were enacted last year in AB 2582 (Adams). 
  • AB 1023, the annual Maintenance of the Codes bill carried this year by Assembly Judiciary Committee Vice-Chair Don Wagner, includes CCBA Resolution 10-01-2010 by the Bar Association of Northern San Diego County, which makes an important technical correction in the law relating to SLAPP suits.

Of the two bills that were held in committee, AB 308, was the biggest disappointment, given the time and effort expended in seeking its passage.  The bill (CCBA Resolution 01-13-2010 by the LACBA) would mandate the creation of new protocols and procedures to better ensure the accuracy of eyewitness identifications in criminal matters.  It was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee due to cost concerns, after the Department of Justice increased its projected cost of the bill to $1.2 million - nearly five times the estimated cost of virtually duplicate measures considered by the Legislature in earlier years. (See earlier post).

SB 490, Senator Loni Hancock's bill to require a public vote on whether California's death penalty should be abolished, stayed in the Assembly Appropriations Committee at the request of the author, who determined that she didn't have the votes to enact the bill (see story in San Jose Mercury News). The decision came only a day after Governor Brown suggested in news stories that he would be supportive of letting the people vote on the question, though without commenting directly on SB 490.  However, it was clear to Sen. Hancock in the all-important process of counting the votes that there simply weren't enough members of the Legislature willing to commit to expending the money to put the issue on the ballot, given polls showing that as many as seven in 10 Californians still support capital punishment for the most heinous of crimes.  The CCBA supported the measure based on its consistent support of resolutions calling for the abolition of the death penalty, most recently 01-01-2010 by the Bar Association of San Francisco. (See earlier post).

Thursday, August 18, 2011

A Suspenseful Legislative Return

The Legislature returned from its summer recess Monday (August 15), and immediately got down to the business of deciding which of hundreds of bills deemed to have fiscal impact should move forward - and mostly which should be held on the Suspense File maintained by each of the Appropriations Committees of the two houses.

The Suspense File is the repository for all bills deemed to have a fiscal impact in excess of $50,000 to the General Fund or private funds, or $150,000 from any other funds.  Bills are placed on the Suspense File over several hearings, so that their aggregate costs can be compared to available revenues.  Then the committee leadership and staff identify which bills should be moved off Suspense and which should be held - a decision that is almost invariably confirmed at the committee's last regularly-scheduled hearing before the deadline for considering fiscal bills.

Even though a bill is earmarked for Suspense does not mean it won't be the subject of extensive and passionate testimony, however, as authors and proponents try to make the case for their bills to be one of the fortunate few that ultimately come off Suspense.  That was the case this week for several bills sponsored or supported by the CCBA.

On Monday (August 15), the Legislature's first day back from its summer recess, the Senate Appropriations Committee considered (see video at 1:25:00) AB 308 (Ammiano), a CCBA-co-sponsored bill to require the development of new protocols and procedures for law enforcement to use in eyewitness identification.  The committee also heard testimony on AB 52 (Feuer), which would require insurers to obtain the approval of proposed rate increases by either the Department of Managed Health Care or the Department of Insurance.

John K. Van de Kamp
On Wednesday (August 17), the Assembly Appropriations Committee considered SB 490, Senator Loni Hancock's measure to ask California's voters to repeal the death penalty, given its massive costs and almost total non-application.  Former Attorney General (and frequent CCBA delegate) John Van de Kamp testified in favor of the bill, which is supported by the CCBA.  The hearing can be viewed here (beginning at the 26:00 mark).


All three bills mentioned (and hundreds of others) will be voted on next week, before the August 26 deadline for bills to be heard and reported by fiscal committee.

Monday, July 11, 2011

Six of eight CCBA-Backed Bills Emerge from Busy Weeks of Committee Hearings

The two weeks leading up to the annual deadline for all bills to clear their second-house policy committee are among the busiest in the legislative calendar.  That was particularly true for this year's CCBA Legislative Program, which saw hearings on eight of its sponsored/supported measures - with six moving forward and two running aground.

Much of the action took place in the Public Safety committees of the two houses where, in three separate hearings, two significant CCBA-backed bills were approved, while another significant CCBA-co-sponsored bill fell temporary (we hope) victim to that state's lack of prison beds:
  • The last bill, AB 545 by Assembly Speaker John A. PĂ©rez, would add persons in a dating or engagement relationship to the list of person's protected by the felony domestic violence battery statute (Penal Code §273.5).  The bill, co-sponsored by the Los Angeles District Attorney's office and the CCBA (Resolution 06-05-2009, sponsored by 10 individual delegates), was held in Senate Public Safety Committee at its June 28 hearing (starts at 22:00 mark). See related blog post. 
  • One week later, at its July 5 hearing, the Senate Public Safety Committee approved CCBA-co-sponsored AB 308 (Resolution 1-13-2010 by the LACBA) by Assemblymember Tom Ammiano. The bill would require the Department of Justice, in consultation with the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training, local law enforcement agencies, prosecutors, defense attorneys, and other legal experts, to develop guidelines relating to the collection and handling of eyewitness evidence in criminal investigations. The objective is to ensure reliable and accurate identifications of criminal suspects, and to minimize the chance of suspect misidentification, which costs society both through wrongful incarceration of the innocent and the failure to pursue and convict the guilty. (See earlier post)
  • Finally, on July 7, the Assembly Public Safety Committee approved SB 490, Senator Loni Hancock's newly-created bill to put the question of eliminating the death penalty to the voters. (see related blog post).
Three bills sponsored or co-sponsored by the CCBA found their way to the Senate Judiciary Committee, with three different results:
  • The committee waived hearing of AB 1147 by Assemblymember Mariko Yamada, which had won unanimous approval of the Senate Human Services Committee the week before.  The bill, developed by the Women Lawyers of Sacramento (Resolution 03-04-2010), had been double-referred to the Judiciary Committee, but now moves directly to the Appropriations Committee. (See earlier post.)
  • On another double-referral, the committee approved AB 1396 by the Assembly Labor & Employment Committee, which had earlier won approval of the Senate Labor & Industrial Relations Committee.  That measure, from the BHBA (Resolution 04-01-2009), goes directly to the Senate Floor.  
  • The committee rejected AB 699 by Assemblymember Don Wagner, which would have added California to the growing list of states which authorize the use of Revocable Transfer on Death Deeds for estate planning purposes (Resolution 12-06-2009 by BASF).  The bill earlier had passed the Assembly on a vote of 78-1.  Because the author declined to seek and obtain reconsideration, the bill is dead. (See clip, beginning at 1:21:00 mark).
Rounding out the busy two weeks, two bills supported by the CCBA were approved by their respective policy committees. 
  • AB 52 by Assembly Member Mike Feuer, which would require pre-approval of health insurance rate increases (see earlier post), was approved by the Senate Health Committee on a vote of 5-3.  The bill is supported by the CCBA, as consistent with provisions of Resolution 02-02-2010 developed by the Beverly Hills Bar Association. (See earlier post).
  • SB 161 by Senator Bob Huff was approved by the Assembly Education Committee.  The bill, which is consistent with Resolution 04-03-2010 sponsored by the Alameda County Bar Association, would authorize school districts to train non-medical school employees who volunteer, to administer emergency antiseizure medication to students with epilepsy.

Friday, July 8, 2011

CCBA-Backed Bill to Seek End to Death Penalty Advances

Senator Loni Hancock
Legislation supported by the Conference of California Bar Associations to place a moratorium on California's death penalty and place the issue of its retention or repeal before the voters has passed its first test, winning approval of the Assembly's Public Safety Committee (click here for a video of the hearing). The bill now goes to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, where it is expected to be heard in mid-August.

SB 490 by Senator Loni Hancock (D-Oakland), Chair of the Senate Public Safety Committee, was "introduced" on June 28 by deleting its original provisions and replacing them with the death penalty-related language (a process known as "gut-and-amend" in the Legislature). The introduction followed the release last month of a report published in the Loyola Law Review by 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals Judge Arthur L. Alarcon and Loyola Law School Professor Paula M. Mitchell, which calculated that capital punishment has cost California $4 billion since it was reinstated 34 years ago, yet just 13 inmates have been executed -- none in the past five years. The report recommends that voters be given the opportunity either to tax themselves to cover those costs or to eliminate them by ending capital punishment. (See related LA Times story).

The CCBA, which includes both criminal defense attorneys and prosecutors among its membership, has a long history of supporting resolutions (all sponsored by the Bar Association of San Francisco) calling for a repeal of California's death penalty law, (e.g., 01-01-2010, 06-03-2009, 02-21-2008, 03-06-2007, and 04-03-2003), or a moratorium in its application (09-16-2006 and 03-07-2004). Another resolution (03-04-2011) has been submitted for consideration at the 2011 meeting of the Conference in Long Beach.

The hearing produced informative and passionate testimony on both sides, as detailed in the extensive news coverage (see e.g., articles in the Sacramento Bee, San Francisco Chronicle, Vacaville Reporter, and Ventura County Star, and a supporting editorial in the San Jose Mercury-News). Due to time constraints, each side was permitted three primary witnesses. Testimony for all other witnesses was limited to one minute. The CCBA was in the latter witness category; however, the organization's letter in support of the bill was quoted extensively in the official committee analysis of the bill.

The fate of SB 490 is far from certain. Despite the enormous cost and the very real concern about executing the innocent, law enforcement in particular is strongly opposed, contending that its elimination would remove a real deterrent to potential cop-killers. In addition, the death penalty historically has been popular with California voters, so even if a majority of legislators in both houses are willing to put the issue to the voters, there is some question that Governor Brown will sign the bill - and more question still that the voters will approve. Thursday's hearing therefore was just a first step.